Bell, Book, and Murder by Rosemary Edghill

This collection is proof that I do like mysteries sometimes! It was recommended to me by a teacher from high school, so it must be good right? It is, don’t worry.

Title: Bell, Book, and Murder
Author: Rosemary Edghill
Length: 448 pages (paperback)
Setting: Modern day, New York, our universe as far as I can tell
Premise: Bast is a normal person, but in suspicious about the death of a friend in the first book, then people start relying on her to solve mysteries for them. She’s also Wiccan, which isn’t really relevant, but is done quite accurately and therefore deserves praise.


  • Very interesting plot twists, you’ll never see them coming
  • Accurate portrayal of Wicca
  • Well rounded characters, including the main character, who definitely was also duped at one point


  • It’s a little grisly a few times
  • It does have the classic problem that books involving normal people solving mysteries do, in that it seems highly improbable that this would ever happen :-)
  • There are no more books past these three :-(
  • The second one might have taken some liberties with history, but I am no expert
  • Apparently according to mystery readers these books aren’t that hard to figure out (proves how many mysteries I read… I was stumped :-) )

Summary: These stories are a little hard for me to classify, since they aren’t fantasy, but they aren’t really that strong of mysteries, but there is the Wicca element. I guess it’s a fiction that is a bit mysterious? Oh well, they are good stories with a delightful character and I recommend them. They can also be instructional about the Wicca religion if you’ve ever been curious, since they are quite accurate.

Til next time!

About Anya

Book blogger at who loves Sci-fi and Fantasy!
This entry was posted in What A Story - Book Reviews and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s